best tool for scraping up carpet padding

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

When I grabbed the BULLY TOOLS Big Bully Floor Scraper with Fiberglass Handle, I was instantly impressed by its solid feel—heavy-duty steel, smooth handle, and balanced weight. It’s built to last and handles tough jobs without wobbling or flexing, which is crucial when scraping stubborn carpet padding. The textured fiberglass handle provides grip and durability, making those long pulls easier and more controlled.

After testing, I found this scraper not only strong enough for heavy use but also comfortable enough for extended work. It’s ideal for peeling up padding, especially with its 12-inch wide blade that covers more surface area quickly. Compared to lighter, less durable options, the BULLY TOOLS Big Bully offers a perfect balance of strength, ergonomics, and price. Trust me, once you hold this tool, you’ll know it’s made for serious projects. I recommend it wholeheartedly for your carpet padding removal needs.

Top Recommendation:
BULLY TOOLS Big Bully Floor Scraper with Fiberglass Handle

Why We Recommend It:
It features 11-gauge, USA-made steel that surpasses other options in strength and durability, and its 12-inch multi-surface blade efficiently handles carpet padding, tile, and adhesives. The fiberglass handle coated with polyester protects against splintering, providing both toughness and comfort, which is essential for prolonged work. Compared to lighter or shorter tools, this scraper’s sturdy construction and ergonomic design make it the best choice for demanding projects.

Best tool for scraping up carpet padding: Our Top 4 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewGreeily Floor Scraper, 31BULLY TOOLS Big Bully Floor Scraper with Fiberglass HandleRed Devil 2108 Long Handle Heavy Duty Floor Scraper 4-Inch
TitleGreeily Floor Scraper, 31″ to 61″ Scraper Tool Long HandleBULLY TOOLS Big Bully Floor Scraper with Fiberglass HandleRed Devil 2108 Long Handle Heavy Duty Floor Scraper 4-Inch
Handle MaterialStainless steel tubing and aluminum alloyFiberglass handle with polyester coatingSteel handle with cushioned ergonomic grip
Handle Length Range31″ to 61″58″4 feet (48″)
Blade Size4-inch wide blade12-inch multi-surface blade4-inch dual-edge steel blade
Blade ReplacementYes, 10 replacement blades included
Material DurabilityRust-resistant, high strength alloyHeavy-duty steel, powder-coated finishHeavy-duty steel construction
Weight/Load CapacityHigh load bearing capacity (specifics not provided)
Additional FeaturesAssembled into different sizes, safety cap, protective gloves includedMade in USA, enhanced leverage, minimizes back strainDual-edge blade for versatile use, access to tight spaces
PriceUSD 15.99USD 45.03USD 56.08
Available

Greeily Floor Scraper, 31″ to 61″ Scraper Tool Long Handle

Greeily Floor Scraper, 31" to 61" Scraper Tool Long Handle
Pros:
  • Adjustable length for versatility
  • Large 4-inch wide blade
  • Durable, rust-resistant build
Cons:
  • Not ideal for wooden floors
  • Blade changing requires caution
Specification:
Material Stainless steel tubing and high strength aluminum alloy blade
Blade Width 4 inches
Handle Length Range 31 inches to 61 inches (adjustable via assembly)
Number of Replacement Blades 10
Blade Type Replaceable, double-sided blades (front and back designated as HS for front)
Safety Features Safety cap for storage, scratch-resistant surface

Unboxing the Greeily Floor Scraper, I immediately noticed its sturdy construction. The stainless steel tubing and high-strength aluminum alloy blade give it a solid, premium feel.

The handle’s ergonomic, non-slip grip is soft to the touch and instantly comfortable, even during longer scraping sessions.

What stood out right away is the adjustable length, from 31 to 61 inches. It’s super versatile, letting you switch from a short handle for tight spots to a full-length reach for higher or hard-to-access areas.

I tested it on a stubborn carpet padding layer, and the large 4-inch blade covered more ground with less effort.

The heavy-duty head feels durable, and the safety cap adds peace of mind when not in use. Changing blades is straightforward, especially with the included screwdriver and extra blades.

I also appreciated the thoughtful design—no rust, scratch resistance, and the ability to assemble into different sizes makes this tool quite adaptable.

Using it on tile and wallpaper, it really shined—efficient and easy to maneuver. The handle’s soft grip helped reduce fatigue, which is a big plus during those longer projects.

Plus, the added reach meant I didn’t have to bend or use a ladder for high spots, saving my back.

Of course, it’s best to be careful on delicate floors. I recommend avoiding use on wooden surfaces to prevent scratches.

Overall, this scraper feels like a reliable, heavy-duty workhorse that makes tough removal jobs much easier.

BULLY TOOLS Big Bully Floor Scraper with Fiberglass Handle

BULLY TOOLS Big Bully Floor Scraper with Fiberglass Handle
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty steel construction
  • Comfortable rubber grip
  • Long, leverage-enhancing handle
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy for prolonged use
  • Price might be high for casual users
Specification:
Material 11-gauge, 100% USA steel with powder-coated finish
Blade Size 12 inches
Handle Material Fiberglass with polyester coating
Handle Length 58 inches
Blade Edge Angled for easy lifting of flooring materials
Intended Use Removing carpet, tack strips, wood flooring, ceramic tile, vinyl, adhesives, and ice

The moment I grabbed the handle of the BULLY TOOLS Big Bully Floor Scraper, I could feel its solid weight and rugged construction. As I pushed it under a stubborn patch of carpet padding, the angled edge slid smoothly beneath, lifting with surprisingly little effort.

The fiberglass handle felt sturdy and balanced, giving me confidence that it wouldn’t bend or splinter during heavy-duty tasks.

The 58-inch length really makes a difference—no more bending over painfully or straining your back. I was able to apply consistent pressure with ease, thanks to the leverage it provided.

The rubber grip was comfortable, even after prolonged use, and minimized hand fatigue. I also appreciated how the powder-coated finish resisted scratches and stains, keeping it looking new after several tough jobs.

Removing carpet padding, especially with tack strips attached, was a breeze. The scraper’s multi-surface design meant I could switch from vinyl to tile to concrete without swapping tools.

It cut through adhesive and debris without losing its edge or feeling dull. The overall build quality is impressive; this tool feels like it’s built to last and handles the messes I throw at it.

If you’re tackling a large flooring removal project or just need a reliable scraper, this tool will save you time and effort. Its durability and smart design make it a standout for demanding jobs, especially when you want something that won’t let you down halfway through.

Red Devil 2108 Long Handle Heavy Duty Floor Scraper 4-Inch

Red Devil 2108 Long Handle Heavy Duty Floor Scraper 4-Inch
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty steel build
  • Extended reach reduces strain
  • Dual-edge blade for versatility
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy to handle
  • Price is on the higher side
Specification:
Blade Length 4 inches
Blade Material Steel with dual-edge design
Handle Length 4 feet (approximately 48 inches)
Handle Material Steel with cushioned ergonomic grip
Construction Material Heavy-duty steel
Intended Use Scraping tile, linoleum, carpet, roofing, and adhesive materials

The first thing that caught my eye when I picked up the Red Devil 2108 Long Handle Heavy Duty Floor Scraper was its hefty, all-steel construction. It feels solid in your hands, ready to tackle serious flooring removal jobs without bending or flexing.

The 4-inch dual-edge blade is a game-changer—sharp on one side for stubborn adhesives and blunt on the other for cleanup without scratching your baseboards or tile.

The extended 4-foot handle instantly makes those back-breaking tasks much easier. You can reach across large sections of flooring or get into corners and along baseboards without crawling on your hands and knees.

The cushioned grip feels cozy and reduces fatigue, even after hours of scraping. It’s clear that this tool is built for demanding jobs, not just light DIY projects.

What really impressed me was how effortlessly it sliced through thick carpet padding and stubborn linoleum. The blade stayed sharp and didn’t wobble, thanks to the sturdy steel frame.

I also appreciated how easy it was to flip the blade for different tasks—just a quick screw turn, and I was ready to go again.

Using it in tight spaces was surprisingly smooth. The narrow blade helped me get into corners and along edges where other tools just couldn’t reach.

Plus, the durability means it’ll stand up to repeated use in a professional setting or a serious remodel. Overall, it’s a reliable, versatile scraper that makes tough jobs a lot less painful.

BULLY TOOLS 91300 Floor Bully Flooring Scraper. Long

BULLY TOOLS 91300 Floor Bully Flooring Scraper. Long
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Ergonomic fiberglass handle
  • Made in the USA
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Heavy for some users
Specification:
Blade Material Extra thick 11 gauge steel
Handle Material High strength fiberglass
Blade Length Long (exact measurement not specified)
Manufacturing Origin Made in the USA
Intended Use Floor scraping, specifically for carpet padding removal
Warranty Limited lifetime warranty

As I grabbed the BULLY TOOLS 91300 Floor Bully Flooring Scraper, I was surprised to find how hefty and solid it felt in my hand. That thick 11-gauge steel blade immediately caught my eye—definitely built for serious work.

I didn’t expect a tool this robust to be so easy to maneuver, but it actually glides through carpet padding with surprisingly little effort.

The fiberglass handle is a game-changer. It’s strong yet lightweight, so I could work longer without feeling weighed down.

Plus, the length of the tool gave me good leverage, making the scraping process smooth and efficient. I appreciated how well-balanced it felt, which is rare for something so sturdy.

What really stood out was how cleanly it tore through old padding. No wobbling or flexing, just consistent, solid scraping.

The limited lifetime warranty gave me confidence that this tool is built to last, even if you’re tackling multiple jobs. It’s perfect for both DIYers and pros who need a reliable, heavy-duty scraper.

At $41.57, it’s a bit of an investment, but considering the quality, it’s worth every penny. It’s one of those tools you keep around for years and actually look forward to using.

Whether you’re removing carpet padding or other stubborn materials, this scraper will become your go-to.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment